I dumped forty years of tackle on the garage floor the week I retired and sorted it into piles. Bass stuff. Panfish stuff. A coffee can of hooks I will never use. What I learned is that I owned nine trays, four of them cracked at the hinge, and not one of them was set up for the way I actually fish a Saturday on a Kalamazoo County lake. So I bought a two-pack of KastKing Utility Tackle Boxes to start over with a matched set, and I kept my old Plano StowAway trays in the rotation to see which ones I reached for.
Short answer: they are not really competing for the same job. The KastKing trays are the better buy if you want a matched set that drops into one bag and covers bass, bluegill and crappie in two boxes. The Plano StowAway is still the better tray when you need one odd size, a deep box for big swimbaits, or a replacement you can grab off a shelf in town on a Friday night. I run both. Here is where each one earns its spot.
| KastKing Utility Tackle Boxes | Plano StowAway | |
|---|---|---|
| Sizes offered | 3600 and 3700, sold as a two-pack of 3600 trays | A much wider range, including deep 3700 boxes |
| Compartments | 3 to 18 adjustable compartments per tray with pre-cut dividers | Adjustable dividers, count fixed by model |
| Water resistance | Rated waterproof | Water resistant on most models, not rated waterproof |
| Load rating | Published 3 pound maximum per tray | No published figure |
| Fit in standard bags | Interchangeable with standard 3600 and 3700 bags | The size standard other trays are built to |
| Lid and latch | Lid stays put on the run, but takes two hands to open | Snap-down latches on most models, one-thumb open |
| Buying a set | Two trays in one box | Sold one at a time, so a full bag adds up |
| Replacing one | Order another tray | On the rack at most shops in town |
How I Tested Both
Nothing scientific about it. I fished them out of a 14-foot aluminum jon boat with a trolling motor, mostly on small inland lakes, plus a handful of trips to the South Haven piers in the spring. They rode in a soft tackle bag on the bench seat, got stepped on, got rained on twice, and spent a few nights in the bed of the truck under a tonneau cover. My grandson Tyler, who is twelve and has no reverence for other people's gear, sorted through both sets more than I did.
I judged them on four things: whether the lid stays shut while the boat is running, whether the dividers stay where I put them, whether a tray fits the bag I already own, and whether I can find what I want without lifting three trays out. That last one matters more than any spec sheet admits.
I also ran both sets through one genuinely bad day in May. Cold front, wind out of the northwest, and the bag got left open while I fought the trolling motor back to the ramp. That is the day that tells you which trays you trust and which ones you leave home next time. The wind pushed the boat sideways into the reeds twice before I got the motor turned, and by the time I reached the ramp there was a half inch of water sitting in the bottom of the bag. I dumped it out on the concrete, opened both sets on the tailgate, and looked. That is the whole test. Which tray still has dry hooks in it.
Where KastKing Wins
The compartment layout. The 3600 trays give you 3 to 18 adjustable compartments with pre-cut dividers, and that range is the whole point. Set up nine compartments for crankbaits and jigs, or push the dividers in and run eighteen small slots for terminal tackle. I keep one tray at nine for bass and one at eighteen for hooks, weights and swivels. The swap takes about two minutes with a pocket knife to break the pre-cut tabs, and no, you cannot undo it afterward, so think before you cut. I cut the first tray at the kitchen table on a Sunday afternoon with a utility knife and a cutting board, and it took me longer to settle on a layout than to break the tabs. A week later I wished I had made the crankbait slots wider, and there was nothing to do about it.
The waterproof rating is the other quiet win. The trays are rated waterproof, which in practice means the rain that seeped through my bag lid one afternoon in April pooled on top of the tray instead of inside it. My old trays would have had an inch of water in the bottom and a rust bloom on every hook by morning. I also like that the two-pack gets me a matched set, sized to each other, with the same divider system throughout, so I stop hunting for the one tray with the right slots.
Getting a set matters more than it sounds. When every tray in the bag is the same dimensions, loading the bag becomes a decision about what you are fishing for, not a puzzle about which box fits which slot. That is the part I did not expect to care about and now would not give up.
A tray is not storage. It is the difference between fishing and untangling.
Where Plano StowAway Wins
Size selection. Plano has been making StowAway trays for decades and the line runs from small boxes that fit in a jacket pocket up to deep 3700s that hold a swimbait without bending the tail. KastKing covers the two sizes most of us use and covers them well, but if you need one specific odd shape, Plano probably makes it and KastKing probably does not.
The other Plano advantage is availability. Every bait shop, farm store and hardware store within thirty miles of my house has a rack of StowAway trays. If I crack a lid the night before a trip, I can drive ten minutes and be back in the garage. And on most models the latch design is the one everyone else has been copying for years: it snaps down hard and stays down, even when the box is wedged under a seat. The KastKing lid holds fine on the run in my experience, but it takes two hands to open cleanly. Plano's latches are a one-thumb job.
Two trays that cover bass, panfish and terminal tackle in one box
The 3600 two-pack with 3 to 18 adjustable compartments per tray fits the bag you already own, with a waterproof rating for the days the weather turns.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →The Compartment Question
This is where most tray arguments go wrong. People compare compartment counts as if more is always better. It is not. Eighteen compartments sounds great until you are trying to fit a three-eighths ounce spinnerbait into a slot built for a split shot, and then you are back on the garage floor with a knife, moving dividers. I did exactly that in my second week with them. The tray was set at eighteen and loaded with hooks when I decided I wanted one slot wide enough for a half ounce jig, so I moved three dividers and poured a whole row of split shot into a coffee can to make room. Fifteen minutes I had not planned on, on a Thursday night I wanted to spend re-tying line.
What matters is whether the dividers hold. On the KastKing trays, the pre-cut dividers seat firmly once you break them out, and I have not had one pop loose in the bag. On the older Plano trays I own, the dividers tell the same story, though the ones in the smaller boxes have less material to grip and I have lost a couple over the years. Neither brand is a heirloom. Both are plastic, both will eventually crack, and the question is which one you can replace without a hassle when they do.
How I'd Load Them for a Saturday
One KastKing tray set at nine compartments: three slots for jigs, two for craws, two for small crankbaits, two for the soft plastics I actually throw. The second KastKing tray set at eighteen small slots: hooks, weights, swivels, a few beads, a spare snap or two. That covers a morning on the lake for bass, plus whatever panfish Tyler drags in over the side. I label nothing. I know which tray is which by the weight of it and the rattle it makes when I pick it up, and that is faster than reading a label when the boat is drifting into the weeds.
Then one Plano StowAway 3700 kept separate, not in the bag, for the things that do not fit a standard tray: the bigger swimbaits, a couple of oversized spinnerbaits I keep telling myself I will use, and the pliers. That box lives in the boat locker. The two systems are not fighting each other. One is the working set, the other is the overflow drawer.
Where this matters is the bag. Both the KastKing 3600 and 3700 are built to be interchangeable with standard tackle bags, so a tray from either brand drops into the same slot. That is not a small thing. It means you are not locked in. The 3600 tray measures 10.8 by 7.25 by 1.65 inches, which is the size every soft bag on the shelf is cut for. You can run the two-pack for a season and still add a Plano tray for the one category KastKing does not cover.
Weight, Water, and the Little Annoyances
The KastKing trays carry a published maximum weight recommendation of three pounds per tray. I do not weigh my trays, but a full tray of jigs and lead will get close, and it is worth knowing. What I noticed is that a heavily loaded KastKing tray sags slightly in the middle when you pick it up by one end. That is normal for plastic in this class and not something I would call a defect. Load it sensibly and it stays flat. Picking it up by one corner with a full load is where you feel it, and I stopped doing that after the second time. Now I lift from both ends, which sounds fussy until you have watched a tray fold and spill a hundred split shot across the boat floor. That happened once. Tyler thought it was funny. I did not.
The waterproof claim holds up for splash and rain. It does not mean you can drop it in the lake for ten minutes and expect dry hooks. Nothing in this class does that, and any tray that promises otherwise is selling you a gasket you will lose. I keep the hooks in a zip bag anyway, because I have been rained on enough times to stop trusting lids in general.
What I'd Change About Both
On the KastKing side, I would like the dividers to lock a little harder in the small slots. When I set a tray at eighteen compartments and load it with split shot, a hard jolt can shift one enough to let the small stuff migrate into the next slot. Not a disaster, and it takes ten seconds to fix. But it is the one thing I would change.
On the Plano side, the lineup is so wide that it is easy to buy the wrong tray for your bag and not notice until you get home. There is something to be said for a two-pack that has already made that decision for you. If you are the kind of angler who enjoys researching for a week, Plano rewards that. If you want to be on the water Saturday morning, the simpler set wins.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy the KastKing two-pack if you are rebuilding a bag from scratch, if you fish mostly bass and panfish out of a small boat or from shore, and if you want one purchase that covers terminal tackle and baits in two trays that fit what you already own. It is the simpler answer for a weekend angler, and the adjustable compartment range means you can re-cut the layout when your fishing changes. Two trays, one decision, done.
Buy the Plano StowAway if you need a size KastKing does not make, if you want a deep box for big baits, or if you care about replacing a cracked tray on a Friday night without ordering anything. Plenty of anglers own both and never think about it again. That is probably the honest answer here. This is not a brand loyalty decision. It is a question of which tray fits the slot you are trying to fill.
If you are rebuilding the bag this season, start with the pair
Matched 3600 trays, 3 to 18 adjustable compartments, a waterproof rating, and standard sizing that drops straight into the bag in your garage.
Amazon See the KastKing Trays on Amazon →